Total Pageviews

Search This Blog

Thursday, June 2, 2011

When is giving to education not giving?

From the Long Beach Examiner

By Brian Jones

The word philanthropy has been haphazardly thrown around in the education reform movement. Billionaires Eli Broad, Mark Zuckerberg, Sam Walton, and Bill Gates have donated hundreds of millions of dollars, claiming it is in the name of improving education. The money spent by what is now termed the Billionaire Boys Club is not simply donated; it has strings attached. This transforms philanthropy into a lobbying effort. An example of this was noted in a recent New York Times article by Sam Dillon titled, “Behind Grass-Roots School Advocacy.” The article sources Bill Gates spent $373 million in 2009, and $78 million just in advocacy for groups supporting his policies (2011).

A prime example of a person and advocacy group Bill Gates supports is Yolie Flores of the Los Angeles Unified School Board. A long time “education reformer,” Flores is a big proponent of charter schools. According to the LA Daily Breeze, charter school enrollment has increased by 8,000 to 10,000 students annually the past decade with a 15% increase in the past year alone. In comparison, attendance at regular LAUSD public schools has dropped to the lowest levels in a decade (Llanos, 2010b). To repay Flores’ years of support for charter schools, the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation is providing Flores with a six-figure salary in a newly created advocacy group to further push the charter agenda onto other public school campuses (Llanos, 2010a).

Philanthropy is the desire to donate money to benefit a good cause. Once strings are attached to the donated money, it becomes a lobbying effort. This is a distinction that must be made in the world of education. During a time of cash starved districts, this lobbying money is pushing the reforms favored by the Billionaire Boys Club without regard to success rates. Board members like Flores are being bought; they in turn sell public education to private entities that do not need to answer to the public, leaving regular public schools that are succeeding to slowly decay with no real philanthropists in sight.

Continue reading on Examiner.com Faulty Philanthropy - Long Beach K-12 | Examiner.com http://www.examiner.com/k-12-in-long-beach/faulty-philanthropy?

1 comment:

  1. Check Wikipedia to see Zuckerberg and Gates privileged educational backgrounds. Sam Walton has been dead since 1992, so he's not actually saying anything about education today. If expressed in his biography, his thoughts might have some value, almost 20 years after his death. Eli Broad appears the only legitimate public school graduate living among the four mentioned individuals. If he has been actively engaged in a public school system, he might offer insights worthy of consideration.

    The problem with all four is it's important their foundations be closely associated with the modern school system to help it. This means the school systems and foundation contact people need to have shared goals and a proper plan to achieve those goals. If they are in conflict, results will be haphazard.

    ReplyDelete