Total Pageviews

Search This Blog

Saturday, January 16, 2016

The Uncounted Underground of Teachers

The Times Union ran an article about a first grade teacher who retired early because she felt micromanaged and forced to teach a curriculum that she felt was inappropriate. The Times Union referred to her as part of an uncounted underground of teachers.


Are you part of this uncounted underground? You just might be if:

You have questions about the appropriateness of the curriculum you are forced to teach. You might feel it is developmentally inappropriate, poorly written or lacks the supplemental materials to be successful.

You bemoan the loss of creativity and innovation and have angst that you have been tuned into little more than a robot regurgitating a script.

You are saddened that you know when kids get home their parents won’t be able to help them with their lessons either because the material is too complicated (common core math) or you don’t have books to send home.

You are frustrated with the constant micromanagement of your time by people who don’ know your kids or what they need. 

You are dismayed that you aren’t allowed to take your kids out for recess because you don’t have time as to much to possibly do is jam packed into every day.

You are frustrated by leaders who either weren’t in the classroom or were for just a cup of coffee years ago or by 27 year old academic coaches and assistant principals who think they know more than you because they took the first opportunity they could to get away from kids and out of the classroom.

You are tired of the poor discipline as kids don’t receive consequences for their actions and the lack of support for discipline you get from your administration.

You are scared for your job if you speak up. You are afraid since you are on annual contract you won’t be reappointed or if you are on a professional contract you will be harassed into quitting if you talk about all the things going on.

You feel marginalized by the community, ignored and disrespected by your administration or scared because your students don’t receive consequences for their actions when you got to work. If you are any of these things they you might just be part of the uncounted underground of teachers.

This so called underground isn’t a handful of dissatisfied teachers with an ax to grind. I feel comfortable saying it is the majority of our staff but please don’t take my word for it, instead ask a teacher how they feel.  I believe at first you will be shocked and surprised but then saddened an hopefully outraged and want to do something.   

The only real chance we have of improving things is if the community gets involved as the district views teachers as easily replaceable cogs. 

We will never reach our potential as a district as long as we marginalize teachers and make them afraid for their jobs. Never, and unfortunately this is the district that we currently have.

Thursday, January 14, 2016

Vitti’s default position about teachers is they suck (rough draft)

There have been lots of issues with the new curriculum. The bottom line is teachers don’t like it and they feel pressured and micromanaged into implementing it.

Vitti’s response is eventually teachers at high performing schools with high VAM (Value added) scores will be allowed to deviate from the curriculum while teachers with low VAM scores and at struggling schools will not.

Oy vey.

First VAM scores are a complicated formula that is supposed to be predictive of what a child learns over the course of a year are wildly inaccurate. They are kind of like asking your cat what the weather is going to be like tomorrow and for the record Captain Slippers says it will be purrrrfect. It’s a catastrophe that VAM scores are being used for anything more than lining the cages of birds.

But teachers have to prove themselves too? Veteran teachers with years of success under their belt, now have to be micromanaged and prove that they know what they are doing? Are we 12 year olds mowing the lawn for the first time? Or are we professionals with degrees and lots of training?   

Then what if you work at a low performing school? Then you are just doomed to be micromanaged forever. Screw creativity, innovation and vision or all the things that made most people want to be a teacher and welcome to reading a prepackaged script that you are never allowed to deviate from.

And all because our superintendent who was a teacher for a cup of coffee a decade ago doesn’t trust nor understand teachers.

We are never going to reach our potential by tying our teacher's hands behind their backs, never.

Vitti wants to double down on a failed curriculum

Superintendent Vitti likes to say that teachers overwhelming picked Engage NY as a curriculum but the truth is this is Vitti’s baby.  Teachers wanted a blended curriculum where they chose from what the district already had which would be supplemented by Engage NY and no teacher chose the level of micromanagement that the district has employed.

From inappropriate subject matter, to a lack of proper resources Engage NY has proven a failure.
The school board knows it too, from the Times Union: 

Several board members questioned his recommendation, some saying they are less inclined to trust the district’s process for selecting instructional materials after their experience with the elementary materials from EngageNY.
Despite concerns from the board, parents and teachers, Vitti wants to double down and bring Engage NY to middle and high school as well.
Also from the Times Union:
Meanwhile, Vitti recommended Tuesday that the School Board buy a new middle school English Language Arts curriculum called Paths to College and Career for use next school year. It would cost the district $1.9 million, he said. Paths comes from Expeditionary Learning, a New York nonprofit which contributed to EngageNY’s curricula.
What does he see that nobody else does? Does he see dollars signs from a future job or is it hubris that prevents him from admitting his mistake.
Here is the thing that he obviously doesn’t get, I believe Engage NY s a disaster as does every teacher I have talked to, everyone but say we are wrong and it’s great, it doesn’t matter, if the super cannot get the buy in from his staff, his bosses and his community then it will never work, but instead of finding something that will he wants more.

We are in trouble and it’s not just the curriculum, it is our leadership too.

Tuesday, January 12, 2016

Duval's disastrous ELA scrimmage, students and teachers set up to fail.

Note: I was sent a picture of all the schools scores and I originally had it up. Later the person who sent it to me contacted me and asked me to take it down. They said they were afraid for their job. I may have disagreed with their choice but I will respect it.

The scores were abysmal and the district average for scoring in the top forty percent was one percent and this is with most of the kids in 9th and 10th grade taking it. The scores were a disaster.

If somebody else sends me the scores I will put them back up but until then this is the best I can do.

The high school ELA scrimmage that was supposed to mirror the upcoming FSA and was given to students just before Christmas.

The results are ridiculously bad. Every school including Stanton and Paxon tanked (and so much for the district testing less right?)

The teachers I am talking to are frustrated with the district. They are telling me that the curriculum is half written and what activities they are given don't match the standards.

Where frustrated with the district they are also frustrated with the state which has given them a constantly moving target. 

With both the state and the district hammering away at them, many teachers feel like they and their students are being set up to fail. 

I am reminded of the old saying, with friends like these who needs enemies.

Sunday, January 10, 2016

Explaining Florida's accountability system

By John Meeks



This perfectly illustrates what it is like to teach in Florida's public schools. In the 16+ years of education reform in our state, there has been little to no consistency in how we hold our public schools accountable. What has been constant is the ongoing moving of the goal posts and changing of the ground rules. I fear that it is impossible to make an apples-to-apples comparison of our yearly progress because the elected and state officials of our state are more interested in playing politics and settling scores than on helping move our public schools forward. Teachers, education support professionals, parents, and all community stakeholders need to speak up today. It's time to stop running our schools by the seat of our pants and it's time to draft public education policy that actually serves our students!


Republicans presidential candidates both dislike and don’t understand children (rough draft)

Before anybody attacks me with righteous indignation just know I have been very critical of Arne Duncan, a historically and secretary of education and President Obama who I believe has had disastrous education policies as well.

Two things republican presidential candidates did this week really caught my eye.

First there was Ben Carson humiliating a fifth grader. He asked his audience of children to point out the worst child in the class and apparently there was a consensus pick. Now Carson can blame the media all he wants but the truth is what he did was unacceptable. But what’s worse is he doubled down saying he would do it again because he didn’t see that he did anything wrong with humiliating the kid.

From the Washington Post:

 Somehow, the word “gaffe” doesn’t quite describe Ben Carson’s latest foot-in-mouth moment. His stumble on the stump in Iowa on Thursday was awkward, embarrassing, possibly painful — anything but funny. And it involved a school kid who — how to put this pleasantly? — perhaps in the view of his fifth-grade classmates does not shine as brightly as they do, and was called out for his shortcomings in front of 500 people at a campaign rally. 

By a man who wants to be president. Later, asked in an interview with WABC’s “Election Central with Rita Cosby” whether he would do it again, he said “absolutely,” saying it helped students understand their potential and accusing the “left wing and media” of making “much to do about nothing.”

Here’s how it went down: Carson has told a story countless times about how he was a “horrible student” who was called “dummy” as a kid. He’s told it in his books and it’s been retold in books about him, including in “Gifted Hands, Kids Edition” — in a chapter called “The Dumbest Kid in Fifth Grade.” Though the veracity of some of Carson’s moral fables has been questioned, he contends his mother took him aside and told him to buckle down or he’d be sweeping floors for the rest of his life. He did, of course, and the rest is history for a retired pediatric neurosurgeon with 38 honorary degrees to prove his worth. It’s inspiring — or, at least, supposed to be inspiring for those kept out of the operating room by lack of ability or opportunity. 


Oy vey. If he really wants this kid to improve and it sounds like some of his classmates think he has room to do so, step one should not be humiliation.
Then Ted Cruz advocating the spanking of five year olds. Not a pop on the wrist or on the bottom but a spanking. When talking about what he would like to do Hillary Clinton he told the following story.
From the Huffington Post:
In my house, if my daughter Catherine, the 5-year-old, says something she knows to be false, she gets a spanking," Cruz said, standing on the bar of a local shop here, looking into the crowd.

In the Democratic primary, Cruz said voters have the opportunity to hold Clinton accountable.

"In America, the voters have a way of administering a spanking," Cruz said with a smirk. "I can tell you this: As president ... there will be accountability for Benghazi."

Now don’t get me wrong, I think kids need discipline and heck in the most sever and extreme situations maybe even a spanking, but to routinely spank a five year old for just being a five year old is ridiculous.
Cruz has a flair for the dramatic and majored in hyperbole so I guess there is a chance he was playing to the crowd but I would suggest he talk to his daughter and explain how lying is wrong instead of spanking her, a lesson if his story is correct, she doesn’t seem to be learning a lesson he should learn too.  

Then once again Chris Christie attacked teacher unions

From the Hill
New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie (R) says real education reform is impossible as long as teachers unions remain a powerful force for the status quo.

“The single most destructive force for public education in this country is the teachers union,” Christie said at a Jack Kemp Foundation panel discussion in Columbia, S.C., on Saturday. “It is the single most destructive force.”

This tired old attack shows a complete misunderstanding about education. Teachers and children fate’s are linked. If it’s bad for kids (high stakes testing for example) it would be bad for teachers. If it’s bad for teachers, making the profession so unattractive people leave, then it’s bad for kids. 
Despite Christie’s assertion to the contrary there is no organization that advocates more for kids than the teacher union’s do.
These guys are completely out of touch.

Saturday, January 9, 2016

It was a bad month for Florida’s Charter schools

 First The KIPP School in Jax was projected to get a D grade and this just months after having received a million and a half dollars of public money through a charter school grant. Its grades thus far have been F B D B D, hardly stellar.


A Charter school in Miami decided not to reopen after the Christmas break. Yep, they said never mind. It’s the 55th to close in Miami Dade alone since 2011.


The principal of another charter school was fired for stealing money, from the charter school. Perhaps she planned to replace the money with grant money that the state had awarded the school.


And imagine that attrition at charter schools are far worse than they are at public schools. Parents should think about the experience or lack thereof of the teachers that work there.


Charter schools as Florida does them are an abomination all you have to do is open a paper to see the evidence.

Do Florida's business community wants our schools to fail?

It sure seems like it.

If you are against the class size amendment and if you are for charter schools and more high stakes tests, then you don’t know anything about education.

The Times Union did an article about how business leaders are concerned over the new school grading formula. They prefer one that would have more kids and schools failing as if half of all tenth graders failing all or part of the recent FSA isn’t enough.

The problem with labeling so many students and schools as failures is the label doesn’t trigger extra resources or help it triggers nothing but penalties and further erodes the confidence that the public has in our schools which is what I think the point of doing so actually is.


The truth is if they ran their businesses like they want our schools to be run then their business would go out of business but maybe that is the point too.

Monday, January 4, 2016

School board candidate wants to rally parents and teachers

From Stacie Dern

Greetings Educators and Parents
My name is Stacie Dern, some of you will recognize my name because of my children and some of you will recognize my name because I pre-interned in your class. I am a parent of a fourth grade child in Duval County and an early education major. I have two older daughters that have been through the system and the differences between the education my 19 and 22-year old daughters received and the one my ten-year old is receiving is stark. I have been to enough pre-intern hours to recognize that what is being taught is not advantageous to the children, nor is it developmentally appropriate in many cases. I am a member of some closed Facebook groups that focus on improving education; groups that encourage parents to have a voice because our current system is bad for our children and unfair to teachers.
        I would like to make a change, which is why I am running for school board seat 7 in the upcoming election this year. I would love to hear your stories and create some publicity in order to bring autonomy back to teaching. Please come to the Avenues mall on Saturday, January 9 at 10:10amnext to Starbucks and tell me how I can help improve a profession with which I am still excited about being a part sometime in the future. It worries me that my son is losing his love of school because it is not engaging, despite the amazing teachers he has. It is the system that is failing him and teachers are being punished for recognizing this failure and not allowed to step in and help. The system is not working so I want to change the system. I went through the 543 pages of email addresses on the Duval County website and copied most of the teachers from elementary and some from secondary school into this email. I excluded the office staff and principals, not because I do not believe in them, but because I do not want to add undue burden on them. 

The upcoming testing and pre-testing will not stop unless we all stand together and make our voices heard. I want to be the voice of those educators who want to speak out, but are afraid. I am still working on my degree and will be doing my official internship in the fall. If I do not win the seat on the school board, I will be applying for a teaching job. It might decrease my chances of being hired, but I cannot be idle when so much is at stake. Children are not numbers and they are not products. My child is not a product that can be stamped “on track for college”, and it’s time to stop treating them as such. Please share this email with family and friends. Thank you for reading.