Total Pageviews

Search This Blog

Friday, January 7, 2011

Huck Finn and Tom Sawyer, to dirty for some schools

WASHINGTON — New versions of Mark Twain classics "Tom Sawyer" and "Huckleberry Finn," cleansed of racial slurs common when they were written, have led many in the US to cry foul.

In the new edition, Huck Finn's travel companion Jim is no longer a "nigger," but instead a "slave." In Tom Sawyer, "Injun Joe" becomes "Indian Joe," among other changes.

The novels were altered by Alan Gribben, a literature professor at Auburn Montgomery University in Alabama, who told National Public Radio that he wanted to save the books, favorites of US children's literature, from disuse because of the controversial language.

"We live in a vastly changed cultural climate, and frankly, I make no apologies for offering this alternative," Gribben, who is white, said of the books originally published at the end of 19th century.

But his revisions have sparked outrage among purists and others who insist the original language is part of what makes the novels a tool for teaching about a difficult part of US history.

"'Adventures of Huckleberry Finn' was written by one of the most prolific and insightful writers and observers of the 19th and 20th century American scene," said Barbara Jones, director of the American Library Association's Office for Intellectual Freedom on aolnews.com.

"Mark Twain was not afraid to highlight all of his country's strengths and foibles. He used the N-word deliberately -- and not because he was a racist," she said.

And on Thursday, The New York Times slammed the revisions under the headline, "That's not Twain."

"We are horrified, and we think most readers, textual purists or not, will be horrified too," it said in an editorial.

"There is no way to 'clean up' Twain without doing irreparable harm to the truth of his work."

From google news:
http://www.google.com/hostednews/afp/article/ALeqM5im7A_EaOril-e9DddZzRJDjrG4oQ?docId=CNG.e83fdace708a2d6c4a7b95b21e5ed3a6.721

7 comments:

  1. Hey Hey Hey,

    Would anyone debate the journalistic integrity of Walt Disney for ommitting the N word from the films Huckleberry Finn, or Tom Sawyer?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Movies are often different from the books they are based on and should we also change passages in the bible to make it politicaly correct?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mark Twain's works are not on my list of sacred texts. If the public could see the texts the publishers contractually delete from current authors, would we be as upset.

    Mark Twain's works have been edited a dozen times for young people, and school kids. Entire portions of text have been edited out, and rewritten for the purposes of using it in education.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Movies are often different from the books they are based on.

    Yes, they are. Where is the public outcry over this?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Furthermore, the texts of the Bible have been rewritten in over 100 different interpretations, and that is just in the English Language. The point I am making, is that the new publisher tried to clean up the language so it would be accepted by the school system, so they wouldn't toss it out. The School system kicked the Bible out about fifty years ago. The same reason this version was edited was the same reason the movie was edited, because they are marketing to kids, who are impressionable, might use that word in the wrong context. When I was a kid, the book was about the clever adventures of Tom Sawyer and Huckleberry Finn, who got the whole neighborhood of kids to paint his fence.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Gee, who is going to be the MOVIE POLICE and have the Movie industry clean up their words on TV and the Movie Screen. More kids pay more attention to the movies and tv, and video games with more racist and violence than any Mark Twain book. What is this world coming to....
    Plus why is everyone trying to erase the past which every country has. The past is that. THE PAST. THAT IS WHAT THIS COUNTRY has. will always have, and unfortunately the next generation will know nothing about what the PAST WAS ALL ABOUT.

    Sort of like the young man on the Million dollar drop tv show., didnt know which came first, the filet of fish sandwich, or the egg mcmuffin,,
    how many out there does??????

    ReplyDelete
  7. "to (sic) dirty" ?

    really---how about "too dirty"

    ReplyDelete